Promptwatch vs Otterly.AI: scored feature by feature (2026)
Promptwatch vs Otterly.AI scored out of 10 in five areas across 30 features, with plan prices, a 100-prompt team priced on both, and where Otterly.AI wins.
Promptwatch and Otterly.AI end up on the same shortlist more often than their prices suggest. Both track how AI engines mention and cite a brand, both offer a 7-day free trial, and both include unlimited seats. Teams that outgrow Otterly usually look at AthenaHQ and Scrunch AI as well, and we scored all of them in our ranked list of Otterly.AI alternatives. This post is the two-way version: Promptwatch against Otterly.AI, scored out of 10 in five areas, with 30 features compared from each vendor's own pages.
Otterly's features page describes it as a content intelligence platform for AI search, and the list behind that is longer than it used to be: URL-level citation tracking, GEO and crawlability audits, Brand Profiling, ChatGPT ads and shopping tracking, Agent Analytics, MCP and an API. Several of those sit on Standard or above, though, and some don't name a plan at all.
Otterly.AI's features page, captured November 8, 2026.
Quick verdict
Promptwatch scores 44 out of 50 and Otterly.AI scores 22. Pick Otterly if you track a short prompt list on its four base engines and the €29 Lite plan covers it. Pick Promptwatch if you need to know why your visibility moved, which crawls and pages caused it, and whether the AI traffic converted, because those rows are where Otterly's pages list nothing or only a beta.
| Area | Promptwatch | Otterly.AI | What decides it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tracking | 9 | 4 | Engine add-ons, 15 prompts on Lite, no personas or prompt volumes listed on Otterly |
| Citations | 10 | 5 | Both have URL-level citations; social reports, offsite mentions and Page Tracker are Promptwatch only |
| Crawler and traffic data | 9 | 3 | Otterly lists beta crawler logs on Standard; conversions and Search Console data are not listed |
| Content | 9 | 4 | Otterly gives recommendations and audits; articles and CMS publishing are not listed |
| Price | 7 | 6 | Otterly is cheaper to start; Promptwatch includes every engine and MCP and API on every paid plan |
| Total | 44 | 22 |
At a glance
| Promptwatch | Otterly.AI | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | Essential $95/mo (€85) | Lite €29/mo |
| Entry allowance | 1 project, 50 prompts, 6,000 responses a month | 15 search prompts, 1 workspace; response allowance not stated |
| Engines | Every paid plan can track any of the supported engines, no add-on fees | ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot in the base price; AI Mode, Gemini and Claude are add-ons |
| Trial | 7-day free trial on all six self-serve plans (monthly billing) | 7-day free trial, no credit card (home and agencies FAQs; the features page sign-up box says 14 days) |
| Seats | Unlimited on every paid plan | Unlimited team members on every plan |
| Annual billing | 12 months for the price of 10 | 15% off |
Full feature comparison
| Feature | Promptwatch | Otterly.AI |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking | ||
| Engines and add-ons | Real interfaces: ChatGPT, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Alexa, Meta AI. Via API: Claude, DeepSeek, Mistral, Grok and more. No add-on fees | 4 base engines on every plan. Add-ons (Lite / Standard / Premium): AI Mode and Gemini €9 / €59 / €149 each, Claude €29 / €109 / €439 |
| Prompt research | Prompt Volumes: volume, difficulty, citation rate (every plan) | AI Prompt Research Tool suggests prompts; volumes and difficulty not listed |
| Query fan-outs | Exact sub-queries per model behind each tracked response | Query Fan Out Tool shows queries engines "may generate"; not tied to tracked answers |
| Personas | Yes, with stacking and Persona Insights | Not listed |
| Location | Country on every paid plan; state and city on Business and agency plans; coordinates (20 m to 5 km) on Business, Agency Scale, Enterprise | Unlimited countries and languages; state, city and coordinates not listed |
| Fastest frequency | Daily; every 12, 6 or 1 hours on Business, Agency Scale, Enterprise | Daily on every plan |
| Coding agent visibility | Codex, Claude Code, OpenCode | Not listed |
| Citations | ||
| Page-level citations | All Citations, URL Positions, Citation Trends with decay half-life per page | Yes, every plan: every cited domain and URL, link-position changes |
| Social citation reports | Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn, Instagram | Not listed |
| Offsite unlinked mentions | Ranked as opportunities | Not listed (recommendations name third-party sites to pursue) |
| Track a specific URL | Page Tracker, incl. competitor URLs | Not listed (Content Audit can audit any page) |
| Crawlers and traffic | ||
| AI crawler logs | Agent Analytics from Professional and on every agency plan | Agent Analytics on Standard (200k events) and Premium (1M); llms.txt says closed beta |
| Bot verification and crawl-to-citation | IP-verified bots, citation rate per page, crawl error explanations | Not listed |
| AI-referred visits and conversions | Every plan, 200K to 15M events | Not listed (a free AI Referral Traffic checker only) |
| Search Console and Bing data | Search Insights in 360 Insights, every brand plan | Not listed |
| Brand and content | ||
| Sentiment and narrative | Brand Narrative, every plan: claims grouped by theme, scored, compared with competitors | Sentiment and Brand Profiling, every plan; claim-level themes not listed |
| Fact check | Business, Agency Scale, Enterprise | Not listed |
| Action queue | Action Board with a weekly Discovery agent | Recommendations: 3 a week on Lite, unlimited on Standard and up |
| Conversational agent | Agent Chat on every plan, Scheduled Chats | No in-app agent listed; MCP (Standard and up) lets an outside assistant query the data |
| Article generation | AEO articles from Professional (5 a month; Business 10) | Not listed; Content Audit produces briefs |
| CMS publishing | WordPress, Webflow, Framer; automated Content Agent on Business | Not listed |
| Content refresh | Diff-style Content Refresh suggestions | Partial: Content Audit suggests improvements for any page |
| Site audit | Weekly, 21 checks, 1,500 to 75,000 pages by plan | GEO, crawlability and content audits on every plan |
| Commerce and ads | ||
| Shopping results | ChatGPT Shopping plus Alexa products, Business and Enterprise | ChatGPT shopping-card tracking, plan not stated |
| Ads inside AI answers | Ads Radar (ChatGPT Search, AI Overviews, AI Mode): Business, every agency plan, Enterprise | ChatGPT and AI Overviews ad tracking, plan not stated |
| Integrations and admin | ||
| MCP server | Every paid plan, 110+ tools | Standard and up (2,000 requests a month; Premium 5,000) |
| REST API | Every paid plan (500 to 50,000 requests an hour) | Standard and up (2,000 requests a month; Premium 5,000) |
| Looker Studio | Professional and up, every agency plan | Standard and up |
| Reports | PDF of any dashboard; 10 scheduled PDF reports per brand plan | Reports and CSV export; weekly automated reports on the agencies page; PDF not listed |
| Agency structure | Agency plans with unlimited projects, pitch projects and prompts; white-label on Enterprise | Unlimited workspaces from Standard; Agency Partners get pitch workspaces and branded Looker Studio reports |
Sources: Promptwatch's llms.txt, AI agent instructions and pricing page (checked November 4 and 6, 2026); Otterly.AI's pricing page (captured November 6, 2026), plus its features page, agencies page and llms.txt (fetched November 8, 2026). "Not listed" means not listed on Otterly.AI's pricing or product pages, checked November 2026.
Pricing side by side
Promptwatch's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.
Otterly.AI's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026. Prices shown in euros for a visitor in the Netherlands.
Take a realistic mid-sized team: 100 prompts, tracked daily on four engines, with crawler data wanted.
On Otterly, 100 prompts rules out Lite, which has 15 and can't buy extra packs. Standard costs €189 a month and includes exactly 100 search prompts. If the four base engines (ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot) are the right four, that's the bill. If the team needs Gemini and AI Mode as well, add €59 each on Standard and the total is €307 a month for six engines. Claude would add €109 more. Standard also brings Agent Analytics with 200k events, MCP and API access at 2,000 requests a month each, and the Looker Studio connector. The response allowance isn't stated.
On Promptwatch, 100 prompts is more than Essential's 50, so the team lands on Professional at $245 a month (€205 in euros). That plan has 150 prompts and 18,000 responses a month. A hundred prompts on four engines every day is 12,000 responses, so there's room for 50 more prompts before the cap. Every paid plan can track any of the supported engines, so the choice of four doesn't change the price. Professional adds 25M crawler log events, 1M visitor events with conversions, 5 AEO articles a month, a Knowledge Base, custom reports and Looker Studio.
In euros, that is €205 against €189 for Otterly's base four, or €307 once Gemini and AI Mode are added. The comparison flips at both ends, though. A team with 15 prompts pays €29 on Otterly and €85 on Promptwatch Essential, and Essential has no crawler logs. At the top, Otterly's Premium (€489) includes 400 prompts, while Promptwatch's Business ($579) includes 350, so heavy trackers get more prompts per euro from Otterly.
Where Otterly.AI wins
Otterly has real advantages, and they belong in the verdict.
- Lower entry price. Lite is €29 a month for 15 prompts on four engines with daily tracking. Promptwatch's cheapest plan is €85. Otterly is cheaper to start, with far fewer prompts.
- Crawler data on a cheaper tier. Agent Analytics comes with Standard at €189. Promptwatch's crawler logs start on Professional at €205. The gap is small, and Otterly's version is still labelled a closed beta, but it is cheaper.
- Ads and shopping tracking listed. Otterly lists ChatGPT ads, ChatGPT shopping cards and Google AI Overviews ads. Promptwatch's Ads Radar and ChatGPT Shopping start on Business at $579. Otterly doesn't say which plan includes them, so ask before you count on it.
- More prompts at the top tier. Premium's 400 prompts beat Business's 350.
- Matching policies. Unlimited seats, unlimited countries and languages, and a 7-day trial all match Promptwatch. MCP, the API and Looker Studio arrive together on Standard. Promptwatch puts Looker Studio on Professional, a similar tier, though it includes MCP and the API on every paid plan.
What Otterly.AI is missing
Conversions from AI traffic
AI-referred visits and conversions are not listed on Otterly.AI's pricing or product pages. The only traffic item is a free AI Referral Traffic checker in the footer. In practice, that means an Otterly report can say your visibility score rose, but not whether any of those answers sent a visitor who signed up or bought. Leadership asks the second question. Promptwatch's Visitor Analytics is on every plan and installs with a script, a Google Tag Manager template or the WordPress plugin. Since ChatGPT stopped sending a referrer on October 8, 2026, an "Include ChatGPT UTM referrers" toggle counts utm_source=chatgpt.com visits as ChatGPT again.
Crawler depth: from bot visit to citation
Otterly lists crawler logs. What it doesn't list is what they connect to. Without bot verification, a scraper using GPTBot's user agent counts as GPTBot. Without a link from crawl to citation, you can't tell a page AI never fetched from one it fetched and chose not to cite, and those two problems have opposite fixes. Promptwatch's Agent Analytics checks bots against each operator's published IP ranges, shows a citation rate per page and explains crawl errors. It starts on Professional.
Promptwatch's Agent Analytics page, captured November 8, 2026.
Prompt demand and audience depth
Otterly's prompt research tool suggests prompts, but search volumes and difficulty are not listed, so you choose what to track without knowing which questions people actually ask. Promptwatch's Prompt Volumes adds monthly volume, a difficulty score and a citation rate per prompt on every plan. We explain how those numbers are built in how prompt volumes and difficulty scores are calculated. Personas, state and city tracking, and coordinate targeting are not listed for Otterly either. Promptwatch has personas, and puts state, city and coordinate targeting plus runs every 12, 6 or 1 hours on Business.
Promptwatch's Prompt Volumes page, captured November 8, 2026.
Writing and publishing the fix
Otterly's Content Audit gives briefs and page-level improvements. Article generation and CMS publishing are not listed, so someone on your team still writes and ships every page. Promptwatch includes 5 AEO articles a month on Professional and 10 on Business, and on Business the Content Agent plans, writes and publishes to WordPress, Webflow or Framer on a schedule, with a review inbox if you want to approve each draft.
Claims, fact checks and the sources behind them
Otterly shows sentiment and which attributes AI associates with your brand. A claim-by-theme breakdown is not listed, and neither are fact checks, social citation reports or tracking a single URL. Promptwatch's Brand Narrative (every plan) pulls out each claim AI makes about you and your competitors and scores it by theme. Fact Check (Business) reads your own site for pages that confirm or contradict a claim. Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn and Instagram citation reports and Page Tracker show which outside sources shape those answers.
Who should pick which
- Pick Otterly.AI if you track up to 15 prompts, the four base engines cover your market, and a monthly visibility trend is the report you need.
- Pick Otterly.AI if you track several hundred prompts on the base engines and prompt count per euro matters more than depth.
- Pick Promptwatch if you need crawler data you can trust, conversions from AI traffic, or content written and published from the gaps.
- Pick Promptwatch if you need Gemini, AI Mode or Claude without per-tier add-ons, or local and persona-level tracking.
Our verdict
Otterly.AI is a good, cheap tracker, and for a short prompt list it is hard to beat on price. Promptwatch wins 44 to 22 because it covers what happens after the mention: Agent Analytics shows whether the crawl happened and turned into a citation, and Visitor Analytics shows whether the AI visit converted. If those are the questions on your desk, start the 7-day free trial on Professional, load the prompts you already track in Otterly, and compare the two for a week.
FAQ
Is Promptwatch more expensive than Otterly.AI?
At the entry level, yes: €85 for Essential against €29 for Lite. For 100 prompts with crawler data, the gap is small: €205 for Professional against €189 for Otterly's Standard, or €307 once Gemini and AI Mode are added.
Do both tools track Claude and Gemini?
Promptwatch tracks Claude via API and Gemini through its real interface, with no add-on fee on any paid plan. Otterly sells both as add-ons on every plan.
Can I trial both at the same time?
Yes. Both offer a 7-day free trial, so you can run the same prompt list in each during the same week and compare the results.