Promptwatch vs AthenaHQ: scored area by area, row by row (2026)
Promptwatch vs AthenaHQ scored out of 50 across tracking, citations, crawler and traffic data, content and price, with 30 sourced feature rows and the plan math.
AthenaHQ pitches itself as a way to monitor what AI says, understand why, and take action, and its pricing is built to get you in the door: a free tier, then Starter at $295 a month with 11 models and an action list. Promptwatch covers the same three steps and then keeps going, following each published page through AI crawls, citations, visits and conversions. On paper they look close. Row by row, they aren't.
We scored both out of 10 in five areas, the same way we score every tool on this site. The sources are AthenaHQ's pricing page (captured November 6, 2026), its platform page, agency page and llms.txt (read November 8, 2026), and Promptwatch's pricing page, llms.txt and AI-agent instructions (re-checked November 4, 2026). Where a row says "not listed", it is not on AthenaHQ's pricing or product pages as of November 2026. That is different from "AthenaHQ doesn't have it."
AthenaHQ's platform page, captured November 8, 2026.
Quick verdict
Pick Promptwatch if you need to know why your visibility moved and what it earned. Crawler logs, AI-referred conversions, fan-outs, social citation reports and CMS publishing are on priced self-serve plans. AthenaHQ either doesn't list them or offers a lighter version through an integration. Pick AthenaHQ if you want to start free with an agent over your data, track a single market, and keep within 3,600 responses a month.
The scorecard
| Area | Promptwatch | AthenaHQ | What decides it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tracking | 9 | 7 | Fan-outs, personas, state/city and hourly runs on Promptwatch; AthenaHQ Starter is one country with personas on Enterprise |
| Citations | 9 | 5 | Page Tracker, citation decay and four social networks against sources and Citation Outreach, with URL depth not stated |
| Crawler and traffic data | 9 | 3 | IP-verified crawler logs and native conversions against GA4 and Search Console integrations |
| Content and actions | 9 | 6 | Both have an action list and an agent; Promptwatch publishes to WordPress, Webflow and Framer |
| Price | 7 | 5 | AthenaHQ's free tier is real, but Starter costs more and its API and extra credits are unpriced add-ons |
| Total | 43 | 26 |
The same scores appear in our AthenaHQ alternatives leaderboard, where AthenaHQ lands sixth of seven.
At a glance
| Promptwatch | AthenaHQ | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | Essential $95/mo; Professional $245; Business $579; Enterprise custom | Essential free; Starter $295/mo; Enterprise custom |
| Entry allowance | Essential: 1 project, 50 prompts, 6,000 responses a month | Starter: unlimited prompts inside 3,600 credits (1 credit = 1 AI response), 1-month rollover |
| Engines | Every paid plan can track any supported engine; Claude, DeepSeek, Mistral and Grok via API | Free: 5 models; Starter: 11 models, more on request |
| Free start | 7-day free trial on monthly billing; free AI Visibility Report | Free Essential tier with 300 credits; paid trial not listed |
| Seats | Unlimited on every paid plan | Unlimited on every plan |
| Annual billing | 12 months for the price of 10 | 17% off |
Full feature comparison
| Row | Promptwatch | AthenaHQ |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking | ||
| Prompt research | Prompt Volumes: volume, difficulty, citation rate | Numerical prompt volume estimates on Starter; difficulty not listed |
| Query fan-outs | Yes, exact sub-queries per model | Not listed |
| Personas | Yes, with stacking and Persona Insights | Enterprise only |
| Location | Country on every paid plan; state/city and 20 m to 5 km coordinates from Business | Starter: single country; multi-region on Enterprise; state/city not listed |
| Fastest frequency | Daily; every 12, 6 or 1 hours from Business | Not listed |
| Engine add-ons | None | Extra models on request; extra credits are a paid add-on |
| Citations | ||
| Page-level citations | Citation Trends with first cited, peak and decay half-life per page | Partial: sources and citation intelligence; URL depth not stated |
| Social citation reports | Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn, Instagram | Not listed |
| Offsite mentions | Unlinked mentions ranked as opportunities | Partial: Citation Outreach |
| Track a specific URL | Page Tracker, yours or a competitor's | Not listed |
| Crawlers and traffic | ||
| AI crawler logs | Agent Analytics from Professional | Not listed; robots.txt and llms.txt access management |
| IP verification, crawl-to-citation, errors | Yes | Not listed |
| AI-referred visits and conversions | Every plan, native script, GTM or WordPress plugin | Partial: GA4 integration; Shopify revenue attribution |
| Search Console and Bing | Both, every brand plan | Search Console; Bing not listed |
| Content and actions | ||
| Sentiment and claim narrative | Brand Narrative on every plan | Sentiment listed; claim review on Enterprise |
| Fact checking | Fact Check from Business | Enterprise only (claim review, Oracle discrepancy detection) |
| Action queue | Action Board with weekly Discovery agent | On-page and off-page actions on Starter; Action Center |
| Conversational agent | Agent Chat on every paid plan | Ask Athena, from the free tier |
| Article generation | 5 AEO articles on Professional; Content Agent from Business | Partial: content optimization agent; ACE on Enterprise |
| CMS publishing | WordPress, Webflow, Framer | Partial: Shopify publishing; Webflow and Framer listed as integrations |
| Content refresh | Diff-style Content Refresh | Yes, Starter |
| Site audit | Weekly, 21 checks, every plan | Partial: crawlability and inaccessible-page detection |
| Shopping | ChatGPT Shopping and Alexa from Business | Partial: Commerce Optimization; tracking not stated |
| Ads in AI answers | Ads Radar from Business | Not listed |
| Integrations and admin | ||
| MCP server | Every paid plan, 110+ tools | Not listed |
| REST API | Every paid plan | Paid add-on on Starter; included on Enterprise |
| BI connector | Looker Studio from Professional | Enterprise: Tableau, Power BI, Looker |
| PDF and scheduled reports | PDF of any dashboard; 10 scheduled reports on brand plans | CSV export on Starter; PDF not listed |
| Security | ISO/IEC 27001, GDPR; SSO on Enterprise | SOC 2 Type 2, GDPR, NIST CSF Tier 3; SSO on Enterprise |
| Coding agent visibility | Codex, Claude Code, OpenCode | Not listed |
Pricing side by side
Promptwatch's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.
AthenaHQ's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.
The two price differently. Promptwatch sells prompt and response limits per plan. AthenaHQ sells credits, where one credit is one AI response, and lets you spend them on as many prompts as you like. Here is what that means for two realistic teams, assuming four engines, daily runs and a 30-day month.
A small brand team tracking 50 prompts needs 50 × 4 × 30 = 6,000 responses a month. Promptwatch Essential at $95 covers exactly that: 50 prompts and 6,000 responses. It comes without crawler logs, though. AthenaHQ Starter at $295 includes 3,600 credits, which covers 30 of those 50 prompts. For the rest you either buy extra credits, which AthenaHQ prices on request, or check fewer prompts each day.
A mid-size team tracking 100 prompts needs 12,000 responses a month. On Promptwatch that is Professional at $245, which allows 150 prompts and 18,000 responses and adds crawler logs, 5 AEO articles a month and Looker Studio. On AthenaHQ it is Starter at $295 plus 8,400 extra credits at a price the pricing page doesn't publish. The one-month credit rollover smooths out a quiet month, but it doesn't add volume.
If the team also needs several markets, Promptwatch Business ($579) adds state and city tracking and hourly runs. AthenaHQ's multi-region support is on Enterprise, with custom pricing. Both offer roughly the same annual discount.
Where AthenaHQ wins
AthenaHQ has a real free tier. Essential gives 300 credits across ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Gemini and Copilot, with unlimited users, and Promptwatch has no free plan, only the 7-day trial and the free AI Visibility Report. The Athena AI agent is on that free tier too, while Promptwatch's Agent Chat starts on a paid plan.
The engine list is easier to read. Starter names 11 models on the pricing card. Promptwatch says every paid plan can track any of its supported engines, but its own documents are less explicit about how many engines a brand plan runs at once, so ask during the trial if engine count matters.
Compliance buyers will notice SOC 2 Type 2 and NIST CSF Tier 3 on AthenaHQ's site. Promptwatch lists ISO/IEC 27001 and GDPR, and SOC 2 isn't in its sources. AthenaHQ Enterprise also connects to Tableau and Power BI as well as Looker, where Promptwatch lists a Looker Studio connector. Shopify stores get a Shopify integration that publishes content and attributes revenue, which isn't on Promptwatch's publishing list. AthenaHQ also manages robots.txt and llms.txt for you, where Promptwatch offers free generators. On seats and prompt volume data, the two match.
What AthenaHQ is missing
AI crawler logs
AthenaHQ can manage crawler access, but its pages list no log of which AI bots actually visited. Without one, a team that sees visibility drop on a topic can't tell whether GPTBot stopped fetching the page or fetched it and cited a rival. Promptwatch Agent Analytics, from Professional, logs every AI crawler visit, checks it against the operator's published IP ranges, and reports a citation rate per page. Failed crawls come with an explanation of what went wrong.
Promptwatch 360 Insights topic view, from the Promptwatch changelog. Example project data.
Conversions you can attribute
AthenaHQ connects GA4 to tie visibility to traffic, and Shopify for revenue, so the numbers live in another tool. Promptwatch Visitor Analytics is on every plan and counts AI-referred visits and conversions from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and others through its own script, a GTM template or the WordPress plugin. ChatGPT stopped sending a referrer on October 8, 2026, and Promptwatch added a toggle that counts utm_source=chatgpt.com visits as ChatGPT again. 360 Insights then lays crawls, citations, clicks and Search Console data over each topic, as in the view above.
Fan-outs, personas and local depth
Query fan-outs aren't listed for AthenaHQ, and personas are Enterprise only. Starter tracks one country. That hurts most for brands whose buyers phrase questions differently by role or location. Promptwatch shows the sub-queries each model ran, supports stacked personas, and from Business lets you pin a monitor to exact coordinates, so ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode answer as if asked from that spot.
Promptwatch Local GEO/SEO targeting, from the Promptwatch changelog. Example project data.
Citations beyond the domain
AthenaHQ lists sources, citation intelligence and Citation Outreach. Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn and Instagram citation reports aren't listed, and neither is tracking a single URL. On Promptwatch, Page Tracker follows any URL, including a competitor's, and Citation Trends shows how fast a page ramps up and how quickly its citations decay.
Publishing, MCP and reporting
AthenaHQ's publishing route is Shopify, and its pages don't list WordPress. The API is a paid add-on on Starter, and no MCP server or PDF reports are listed. Promptwatch publishes to WordPress, Webflow and Framer. The automated Content Agent with a review inbox starts on Business, and the MCP server and REST API are on every paid plan. That matters to any team that wants Claude or Cursor to pull the weekly numbers.
Who should pick which
- Pick AthenaHQ if you want to start free, you track one market, and Ask Athena plus the action list cover the job.
- Pick AthenaHQ Enterprise if SOC 2 Type 2 or a Tableau or Power BI feed is a procurement requirement.
- Pick Promptwatch if you need crawler logs and conversions next to your prompt results. Professional is the right starting plan.
- Pick Promptwatch Business if you need city or coordinate tracking, hourly runs, Ads Radar or the automated Content Agent.
Our verdict
Promptwatch scores 43 to AthenaHQ's 26, and the gap comes from the crawler and traffic rows. AthenaHQ tells you what AI said and suggests what to do. Promptwatch also shows whether the bots read the page you fixed, whether it got cited, and whether the visit converted, all in one project. Start the 7-day free trial on Professional, load the prompt list you track in AthenaHQ, and check Agent Analytics after a week to see which of your pages the AI crawlers actually reached.
FAQ
Is Promptwatch cheaper than AthenaHQ?
At list price, yes. Essential is $95 and Professional is $245, against $295 for AthenaHQ Starter. AthenaHQ's free Essential tier costs nothing, though, and on Starter the real cost depends on how many extra credits you buy.
Does AthenaHQ have AI crawler logs?
Not on its pricing or product pages as of November 2026. It lists crawler access management through robots.txt and llms.txt, and detection of inaccessible pages. Promptwatch's crawler logs start on Professional.
Can I compare them without paying?
Yes. AthenaHQ's Essential tier is free with 300 credits. Promptwatch offers a 7-day free trial on monthly billing and a free AI Visibility Report. Run the same prompts in both during the same week.